Common Mistakes in Mathematical Modeling
Learn
Mathematical modeling requires translating real-world situations into mathematical representations. Many errors occur not in calculations but in the setup and interpretation phases.
Common Mistakes and Corrections
Mistake 1: Choosing the Wrong Model Type
Example: Using a linear model for population growth
Why it's wrong: Population typically grows exponentially, not linearly. A linear model will underestimate long-term growth.
Correct approach: Recognize growth patterns—exponential for populations, logistic for resource-limited growth, linear only for constant rate changes.
Mistake 2: Ignoring Units
Example: Calculating speed as 60 when given distance in miles and time in minutes
Why it's wrong: 60 miles Ă· 30 minutes = 2 miles/minute, not 60 mph
Correct approach: Always track units and convert before calculating. 30 minutes = 0.5 hours, so 60 Ă· 0.5 = 120 mph.
Mistake 3: Extrapolating Beyond Valid Range
Example: Using a model based on data from ages 20-60 to predict outcomes for age 90
Why it's wrong: The relationship may change outside the observed range; patterns don't always continue.
Correct approach: State domain limitations and avoid predictions far outside the data range.
Mistake 4: Confusing Correlation with Causation
Example: Ice cream sales and drowning deaths are correlated, so ice cream causes drowning
Why it's wrong: Both are caused by a third variable (summer/hot weather), not by each other.
Correct approach: Correlation indicates a relationship; establishing causation requires controlled experiments or additional evidence.
Mistake 5: Not Checking Model Reasonableness
Example: A model predicts a person's height will be 50 feet based on trend
Why it's wrong: Physical constraints make this impossible—always check if outputs make real-world sense.
Correct approach: Validate model outputs against known constraints and common sense.
Mistake 6: Using Average When Inappropriate
Example: Using mean income to represent "typical" when distribution is highly skewed
Why it's wrong: A few extremely high incomes can inflate the mean significantly.
Correct approach: Use median for skewed distributions; understand which measure of center fits the context.
Practice: Spot the Mistake
1. A student models bacteria growth using y = 100 + 50x (x = hours). After 10 hours, the model predicts 600 bacteria. What's wrong with this approach?
2. A company's revenue model R(t) = 2t² + 5t fits data from years 1-5 perfectly. They predict revenue for year 20. What's the concern?
3. A researcher finds that countries with more cell phones have lower infant mortality rates and concludes cell phones improve health. What's the flaw?
4. A car travels 150 kilometers in 90 minutes. A student calculates speed as 150/90 = 1.67 km/hr. Find and fix the error.
Answers
Click to reveal
- Wrong model type: Bacteria grow exponentially, not linearly. An exponential model like y = 100(2)^(t/period) would be more appropriate.
- Extrapolation beyond valid range: The model may not hold for year 20—market saturation, competition, or other factors could change the growth pattern.
- Correlation vs. causation: Both cell phones and lower mortality are likely caused by higher economic development, not by each other.
- Unit error: 90 minutes = 1.5 hours. Speed = 150 km Ă· 1.5 hr = 100 km/hr. The student divided by minutes instead of hours.