Primary Source Analysis
Learn
This lesson focuses on primary source analysis skills essential for understanding US History and Civics. Primary sources are original documents, artifacts, or other materials created during the time period being studied.
What Are Primary Sources?
- Documents: Letters, diaries, speeches, laws, newspaper articles
- Visual Sources: Photographs, paintings, maps, political cartoons
- Physical Objects: Artifacts, buildings, clothing
- Oral Histories: Interviews, recorded testimonies
The SOAPS Method for Document Analysis
- S - Speaker: Who created this source? What is their background?
- O - Occasion: When and where was this created? What events surrounded it?
- A - Audience: Who was the intended audience?
- P - Purpose: Why was this source created? What message does it convey?
- S - Subject: What is the main topic or idea?
Evaluating Source Reliability
Consider these questions when analyzing any primary source:
- What bias might the creator have?
- Is this a firsthand or secondhand account?
- Does this source corroborate with other evidence?
- What perspective or voice might be missing?
Examples
Work through these examples of primary source analysis.
Example 1: Frederick Douglass's Speech (1852)
"What, to the American slave, is your Fourth of July? I answer: a day that reveals to him, more than all other days in the year, the gross injustice and cruelty to which he is the constant victim."
SOAPS Analysis:
- Speaker: Frederick Douglass, formerly enslaved person, abolitionist leader
- Occasion: July 5, 1852, Rochester, NY - invited to speak about Independence Day
- Audience: White abolitionists and reform-minded citizens
- Purpose: To highlight the hypocrisy of celebrating freedom while slavery existed
- Subject: The contradiction between American ideals and the reality of slavery
Example 2: Analyzing a Political Cartoon
Source: "The Bosses of the Senate" (1889) by Joseph Keppler
Analysis:
- Visual Elements: Large, bloated figures representing trusts looming over small senators
- Symbolism: Size represents power and influence of big business
- Message: Corporations controlled the government during the Gilded Age
- Perspective: Progressive/reform viewpoint critical of corporate power
Practice
Apply your primary source analysis skills to these exercises.
Practice 1: Gettysburg Address Excerpt
"Four score and seven years ago our fathers brought forth on this continent, a new nation, conceived in Liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal."
Use the SOAPS method to analyze this excerpt. What was Lincoln's purpose, and how does the historical context shape its meaning?
Practice 2: Comparing Perspectives
How might an account of Reconstruction written by a former Confederate differ from one written by a formerly enslaved person? What questions would you ask about each source?
Practice 3: Evaluating Reliability
A newspaper article from 1885 describes factory conditions as "excellent" and workers as "satisfied." What factors would you consider when evaluating this source's reliability?
Check Your Understanding
Test yourself with these 10 quiz questions. Click each question to reveal the answer.
1. What is a primary source?
Answer: A primary source is an original document, artifact, or other material created during the time period being studied, by someone who directly experienced or witnessed the events described.
2. What does the "O" in SOAPS stand for, and why is it important?
Answer: The "O" stands for Occasion - when and where the source was created and what events surrounded it. This is important because historical context shapes the meaning and significance of any source.
3. How does a primary source differ from a secondary source?
Answer: A primary source is created during the time period being studied by someone with direct experience, while a secondary source analyzes, interprets, or comments on primary sources and is created after the fact (like textbooks or documentaries).
4. Why is it important to consider the author's bias when analyzing a source?
Answer: Every author has a perspective shaped by their background, beliefs, and purpose. Understanding bias helps us interpret the source more accurately and recognize what information might be emphasized, omitted, or distorted.
5. Give two examples of primary sources from the Reconstruction era.
Answer: Examples include: the 13th, 14th, or 15th Amendments; Freedmen's Bureau records; letters from formerly enslaved people; speeches by Frederick Douglass; Southern state Black Codes; newspaper articles from the period; photographs of the era.
6. What is corroboration and why is it important in historical analysis?
Answer: Corroboration is comparing multiple sources to see if they support or contradict each other. It's important because no single source tells the complete story, and finding agreement across sources increases confidence in historical conclusions.
7. How might a political cartoon be useful for understanding the Gilded Age?
Answer: Political cartoons reveal public attitudes and concerns of the time. They show how people viewed issues like corporate power, corruption, immigration, and inequality. They're useful for understanding perspectives but must be analyzed for the cartoonist's bias.
8. What questions should you ask about the audience of a primary source?
Answer: Who was the intended audience? How might the audience affect what the author included or excluded? Would the author present information differently to a different audience? Was this meant to be public or private?
9. Why might oral histories from formerly enslaved people (like the WPA narratives) require careful analysis?
Answer: These narratives were recorded decades after slavery by white interviewers during the Jim Crow era. The interviewees might have altered their accounts due to fear, the power dynamics present, memory changes over time, or the questions asked.
10. What perspective is often missing from primary sources about industrialization?
Answer: The perspectives of workers, immigrants, women, children, and the poor are often underrepresented because they had less access to education and publishing. Most surviving documents were created by wealthy, educated, white men in positions of power.
Next Steps
- Practice analyzing primary sources from different time periods
- Move on to Claim-Evidence Writing to apply these skills
- Visit archives or digital collections to explore more primary sources