Primary Source Analysis
Learn
Primary sources are original, firsthand accounts from the time period being studied. Learning to analyze them is essential for understanding history and building evidence-based arguments.
What Are Primary Sources?
- Documents: Letters, diaries, speeches, government records, newspapers from the era
- Visual sources: Photographs, paintings, maps, political cartoons
- Physical objects: Artifacts, clothing, tools, buildings
- Oral histories: Recorded interviews with people who lived through events
The SOAPS Method for Analysis
| Letter | Meaning | Questions to Ask |
|---|---|---|
| S | Speaker/Source | Who created this? What was their background? |
| O | Occasion | When and where was this created? What was happening? |
| A | Audience | Who was this intended for? |
| P | Purpose | Why was this created? What did the creator want to achieve? |
| S | Subject | What is this about? What is the main message? |
Evaluating Reliability and Bias
- Consider perspective: Every source reflects the viewpoint of its creator
- Look for corroboration: Do other sources support this information?
- Identify limitations: What might be missing or exaggerated?
- Understand context: How did the time period influence the creator?
Examples
Example 1: Analyzing a Historical Letter
Source: A letter from a Civil War soldier to his family, dated 1863
SOAPS Analysis:
- Speaker: Union soldier, likely enlisted man based on writing style
- Occasion: Written during the Civil War, possibly after a battle
- Audience: Family members at home
- Purpose: To reassure family, share experiences, maintain connection
- Subject: Daily life as a soldier, conditions in camp, thoughts on the war
Reliability note: Personal letters are valuable for understanding individual experiences but may minimize hardships to avoid worrying family.
Example 2: Analyzing a Political Cartoon
Source: A political cartoon from 1900 about industrialization
SOAPS Analysis:
- Speaker: Editorial cartoonist, likely working for a newspaper
- Occasion: Period of rapid industrial growth and labor disputes
- Audience: Newspaper readers, general public
- Purpose: To comment on/criticize aspects of industrialization
- Subject: The relationship between workers and factory owners
Reliability note: Political cartoons deliberately exaggerate to make a point; they reveal attitudes of the time but are not objective reporting.
Practice Quiz
Test your understanding with these 10 questions. Click on each question to reveal the answer.
1. What makes something a primary source rather than a secondary source?
Answer: A primary source is an original, firsthand account created during the time period being studied by someone who experienced or witnessed the events. Secondary sources analyze or interpret primary sources after the fact.
2. What does the "O" in SOAPS stand for, and why is it important?
Answer: "O" stands for Occasion - when and where the source was created and what was happening at the time. This context helps us understand why the source says what it does and what influences shaped it.
3. A diary from 1920 describes life during Prohibition. Is this a primary or secondary source?
Answer: Primary source. The diary was written during the Prohibition era by someone living through it, providing a firsthand account of the time period.
4. Why should historians look for corroboration when analyzing primary sources?
Answer: Corroboration (finding supporting evidence from other sources) helps verify accuracy and reduce the impact of individual bias. If multiple independent sources agree, the information is more likely to be reliable.
5. A government report claims a policy was successful. What bias concern should you consider?
Answer: The government has an interest in portraying its own policies positively. The report may emphasize successes while minimizing failures. Look for independent sources or opposing viewpoints to get a complete picture.
6. What is the "Purpose" question in SOAPS analysis asking you to determine?
Answer: Why the source was created and what the creator hoped to achieve. This might include persuading, informing, entertaining, recording, or protesting. Understanding purpose helps identify potential bias.
7. A newspaper from 1860 provides a detailed account of a political speech. What limitations might this source have?
Answer: The newspaper might have a political bias that affected how it reported the speech. It might have quoted selectively, added editorial comments, or interpreted the speech according to its own views. Different newspapers might report the same speech very differently.
8. Why are photographs valuable primary sources, and what caution should you exercise with them?
Answer: Photographs capture visual evidence of people, places, and events from the past. However, photographers choose what to photograph and from what angle, photos can be staged or manipulated, and they show only a single moment that may not represent typical conditions.
9. An oral history interview was conducted in 2010 about events from 1960. What should you consider when using this source?
Answer: Memory changes over time - details may be forgotten, embellished, or influenced by later events. The person's perspective may have changed over 50 years. However, oral histories capture personal experiences and emotions that written records might miss.
10. How can understanding the "Audience" of a primary source help you analyze it?
Answer: Knowing the intended audience helps explain the tone, content, and purpose of a source. A private diary differs from a public speech; a letter to family differs from an official report. Creators adjust their message based on who will receive it.
Check Your Understanding
You should now be able to:
- Identify different types of primary sources
- Apply the SOAPS method to analyze any primary source
- Evaluate the reliability and bias of historical sources
- Understand how context affects source interpretation
Next Steps
- Review any concepts that felt challenging
- Move on to the next lesson when ready
- Return to practice problems periodically for review