Primary Source Analysis
Learn
Primary sources are original documents, artifacts, or evidence created during the time period being studied. In government and economics, primary sources include founding documents, legislative records, speeches, economic data, court decisions, and policy statements. Learning to analyze these sources is essential for understanding how democratic institutions function and how economic policies develop.
What Are Primary Sources?
Primary sources provide direct, firsthand evidence about an event, object, person, or work of art. They are created at the time of the events they describe or by participants in those events. In the context of American government and economics, primary sources include:
- Founding Documents: The Constitution, Declaration of Independence, Federalist Papers, Anti-Federalist Papers
- Legislative Records: Bills, laws, congressional debates, committee reports
- Executive Documents: Presidential speeches, executive orders, State of the Union addresses
- Judicial Opinions: Supreme Court decisions, dissenting opinions, legal briefs
- Economic Data: Census records, Bureau of Labor Statistics reports, Federal Reserve publications
- Policy Documents: White papers, agency regulations, budget proposals
The SOAPS Method for Document Analysis
Use SOAPS to systematically analyze any primary source:
- Speaker: Who created this document? What is their position, background, or authority?
- Occasion: What historical context or event prompted this document?
- Audience: Who was the intended audience? How might this affect the content?
- Purpose: Why was this document created? What was the author trying to accomplish?
- Subject: What is the main topic or argument of the document?
Evaluating Source Reliability
When analyzing primary sources, consider:
- Authenticity: Is this document genuine? Can its origin be verified?
- Bias: What perspective does the author bring? What might be omitted or emphasized?
- Corroboration: Do other sources support or contradict this account?
- Historical Context: What was happening at the time that influenced this document?
Reading Economic Data as Primary Sources
Economic indicators and data sets are primary sources that require specific analytical skills:
- Identify the source agency and its methodology
- Understand what the data measures and what it does not measure
- Consider the time period and any significant events that may affect the data
- Look for trends, patterns, and anomalies
- Distinguish between correlation and causation
Examples
Example 1: Analyzing the Preamble to the Constitution
"We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America."
SOAPS Analysis:
- Speaker: The Constitutional Convention delegates, speaking collectively as "We the People"
- Occasion: 1787, after the Articles of Confederation proved too weak for effective governance
- Audience: The American people, state ratifying conventions, and future generations
- Purpose: To establish legitimacy for the new government and outline its fundamental goals
- Subject: The creation of a new constitutional framework with specific objectives
Example 2: Interpreting Economic Data
Consider this excerpt from Bureau of Labor Statistics data:
"The unemployment rate declined to 3.7 percent in November, while nonfarm payroll employment rose by 199,000."
Analysis Questions:
- What does "unemployment rate" measure? (People actively seeking work who cannot find it)
- What does it NOT measure? (Discouraged workers, underemployed, gig workers)
- How is "nonfarm payroll employment" different from total employment?
- What context is needed to interpret 3.7%? (Historical averages, recent trends)
Practice
Apply your primary source analysis skills to these questions.
1. A primary source differs from a secondary source because a primary source:
2. When analyzing a presidential speech using SOAPS, which question addresses "Occasion"?
3. A researcher finds that an 1850 newspaper article about slavery was written by a plantation owner. This information is most useful for evaluating the source's:
4. The Federalist Papers are considered primary sources for understanding the Constitution because they:
5. When the Bureau of Labor Statistics reports the unemployment rate, a critical reader should consider that the rate may NOT include:
6. Which of the following would be considered a primary source for studying the 2008 financial crisis?
7. A Supreme Court dissenting opinion is valuable as a primary source because it:
8. Corroboration in source analysis means:
9. An executive order is a primary source that demonstrates:
10. When analyzing a graph from a Federal Reserve report, which question is LEAST relevant to evaluating its reliability?
Check Your Understanding
Answers:
- B - Primary sources are created at the time of the event or by participants
- B - "Occasion" addresses the historical context or events prompting the source
- B - Knowing the author was a plantation owner helps identify potential bias
- C - The Federalist Papers were written by Hamilton, Madison, and Jay to explain constitutional intent
- B - The unemployment rate excludes discouraged workers who have stopped seeking employment
- B - Congressional testimony from 2008 is a firsthand account from the time period
- B - Dissenting opinions reveal alternative legal interpretations debated at the time
- B - Corroboration involves checking other sources for confirmation or contradiction
- C - Executive orders are direct evidence of presidential policy and executive authority
- C - The designer's color preference is irrelevant to data reliability
Next Steps
- Practice the SOAPS method with different types of government documents
- Compare primary and secondary sources on the same historical event
- Continue to the next lesson: Maps and Data